Pivotal Book
Review
You
Can't Say You Can't Play
by Vivian Gussin Paley
From the
reviews
I picked up this book at my daughters' school
parent lending library- a school that works hard to
implement policies like 'you can't say you can't play' (YCSYCP)
and it often works. It certainly works inter-age but
problems remain between age-mates. I, too, was a rejected
child many times and hate to see any child rejected.
Paley--a kindergarten teacher at the
University of Chicago Laboratory Schools, a MacArthur grant
recipient and the author of The Boy Who Would Be a
Helicopter --explores how to keep students from being
ignored by their classmates. She describes what happened
when she asked students ranging from kindergarten to fifth
grade to debate the proposition "You Can't Say You Can't
Play." Woven throughout Paley's lessons is a parable about
loneliness and rejection, which enables readers to share a
child's view of the world. What the kids have to say is
enchanting and surprisingly wise. For example, should a
"boss" determine who plays with whom, or should there be an
election? As a sagacious second-grader observes: "See, the
bad thing about voting is, if you don't vote for that person
she'll see all the people who don't like her. If it's a boss
that's only one person doesn't like you so you don't feel so
bad.
The changes in
the classroom as a result of 'YCSYCP' were interesting since
the children overall became more inventive and more
welcoming, as the author hoped they would. The author was
able to define changes she had made in her classroom- like
eliminating time-outs- as part and parcel of 'YCSYCP'. I
think the simple language worked for these children and
could be a good starting place for even older children. As
the children mature in their understanding of what happens
when the habit of exclusion is broken, they will be able to
step back and examine exclusion and rejection in more
philosophical terms.
I think this
book and others you can find like it are worthwhile as
people search for ways to make schools more humane and
functional for all students, not just the favored.
Its relevance goes far beyond the
kindergarten classroom, which is the setting of Paley's
story.
This book is
available from
Amazon
List Price:$15.50
You pay:
$13.05
|
Pivotal
Gold members,
click here to
get your copy for free (one
book per month)
... Not a Pivotal Gold
member? More
information
here.
Join up and then come back
get your free book for the
month. |