Only a
short time
after
husband-and-wife
entrepreneurs
Karen
Cooley and
Eric
Favier
bought a
friend's
restaurant
in 1991,
they had
their
first
taste of
success.
Sales at
their
Tallahassee,
Florida,
restaurant,
Chez
Pierre,
had more
than
doubled in
response
to savvy
marketing
and
expanded
kitchen
hours. But
after five
successful
years at
the
location,
the
federal
government
acquired
the
restaurant's
property
to expand
a nearby
courthouse.
'We were
given one
of those
‘When
life gives
you
lemons,
make
lemonade'
kind of
scenarios,
and we had
to move
our
business,'
says
Cooley,
48.
So the
couple
took
another
leap of
faith,
buying and
renovating
a
commercial
building
for $1.2
million to
house the
restaurant.
It marked
a major
entrepreneurial
milestone
for Cooley
and Favier,
who had
previously
leased
restaurant
space from
the
original
Chez
Pierre
owners.
Not only
did they
now own
their own
building,
but they
were also
knee-deep
in debt
because of
the
purchase.
'It was
really
challenging,
and we
weren't
sure where
to go next
[or] what
to do,'
says
Cooley.
For help
managing
the debt
and
charting a
new course
for the
business,
the couple
turned to
The Jim
Moran
Institute
for Global
Entrepreneurship
at Florida
State
University.
Among
other
things,
they were
advised to
intensify
marketing
and build
up sales
to help
offset the
loan
payments.
Eventually,
sales more
than
doubled to
nearly $2
million
annually
in
response
to their
strong
marketing
efforts.
Marketing
strategies
included
community
networking,
such as
raising
money for
causes
like
cancer
research,
and
publicizing
the
restaurant's
off-site
catering
and other
services.
'We had
many
sleepless
nights,'
Cooley
says of
their
decision.
'But it
has turned
out to be
absolutely
the right
thing to
do. We
have so
many
different
avenues
for
growing
our
business
right
now.'
The couple
has since
added team
operating
partner
David
Michael
Sprowles
and is
gearing up
for
another
round of
financing
to further
boost
sales.
Cooley and
Favier,
50, plan
to build
an outdoor
dining
area that
will
include a
wood-burning
pizza oven
and a
seafood
bar. If
you're
going to
take on
more debt,
Cooley
says, it
not only
has to
generate
enough in
sales and
profitability
to take
care of
the debt
service,
but [also]
put money
back in
the
coffers.
None of us
has a
crystal
ball, she
explains.
You're
always
trying to
find that
balance
between
having a
successful
business
that is
growing
organically
and
knowing
when it
takes time
to go
beyond
that and
put in
more
investment
for
infrastructure
or new
facilities.
It's tough
to do.
A
Balancing
Act
Indeed,
taking on
the right
amount of
debt can
mean the
difference
between a
business
struggling
to survive
and one
that can
respond
nimbly to
changing
economic
or market
conditions.
A number
of
circumstances
may
justify
acquiring
debt. As a
general
rule,
borrowing
makes the
most sense
when you
need to
bolster
cash flow
or finance
growth or
expansion.
But while
debt can
provide
the
leverage
you need
to grow,
too much
debt can
strangle
your
business.
So the
question
is: How
much debt
is too
much?
The
answer,
experts
say, lies
in a
careful
analysis
of your
cash flow
as well as
your
industry.
A business
that
doesn't
grow dies,
says Jerry
Osteryoung,
executive
director
of The Jim
Moran
Institute.
You've got
to grow,
but you've
got to
grow
within the
financial
constraints
of your
business.
What is
the ideal
capital
structure
a business
needs in
its
industry
to remain
viable?
The higher
the
volatility
[in your
industry],
the less
debt you
should
have. The
smaller
the
volatility,
the more
debt you
can
afford.
Do Your
Homework
To
find out
where your
business
stands,
carefully
examine
your
company's
debt-to-equity
ratio,
which can
help you
keep debt
within
reasonable
limits.
The ratio
is derived
by looking
at a
company's
long-term
debt
divided by
its
equity.
Lower
ratios
typically
indicate
that the
business
is well
within its
borrowing
capacity
and can
weather
cyclical
or
seasonal
downturns.
Bear in
mind,
however,
that this
benchmark
can vary
widely by
industry.
As a
result,
you will
want to
identify a
debt-to-equity
ratio
specific
to your
business,
which can
reveal
whether
you need
to pay
down debt,
postpone
borrowing
plans or
even
secure an
investment
to get
your
business
on track.
To get
started,
check out www.bizstats.com,
which
provides a
useful
online
listing of
average
debt-to-equity
ratios by
industry.
Although
banks and
other
financial
institutions
look for a
satisfactory
debt-to-equity
ratio
before
agreeing
to make a
loan,
don't
assume a
creditor's
willingness
to extend
funds is
evidence
that your
business
is in a
strong
debt
position.
Some
financial
institutions
are
overzealous
lenders,
particularly
when
trying to
lure or
hold on to
promising
business
customers.
I've seen
cases
where
banks have
[lent] way
too much
to a
business,
Osteryoung
says.
Grant
Lacerte,
owner of
Winter
Haven, Florida-based
Financial
Research
Associates,
agrees.
The bank
may be
looking
more at
collateral
than
whether
the
[business's]
earnings
are going
to come in
to justify
the debt
service,
says
Lacerte,
whose
company
publishes
small-business
financial
studies.
As an
owner of
two
businesses,
Lacerte
says he is
constantly
inundated
with
credit
card
offers for
working
capital
and lines
of credit,
many from
large
banking
institutions.
'The bank
is not
[conducting]
any
financial
analysis
on the
business's
financials,'
he says.
'They just
go by the
creditworthiness
of the
firm based
on its
past
bill-paying
experience.
They're
not
looking at
the real
worth of
the
business
and the
ongoing
ability to
pay off
that debt.
'In the
old days,
a
commercial
loan
officer
would do a
credit
analysis.
[Today,] I
see small
businesses
not even
doing
seven
figures in
revenue
[being]
offered a
$100,000
credit
line just
like
that,'
Lacerte
says.
To avoid
these and
other
credit
pitfalls,
it's up to
you to get
the
financial
facts on
your
business
and make
sound
borrowing
decisions.
Unfortunately,
many
entrepreneurs
fail to
recognize
how
important
financial
analysis
is to
running a
successful
business.
Even
business
owners who
receive
detailed
financial
statements
from their
accountants
often do
not take
advantage
of the
valuable
information
contained
in the
documents.
Even
though
getting a
handle on
these
things
might seem
like an
intimidating
task, not
having an
accounting
degree is
no excuse,
says
Lacerte,
who is
developing
a
web-based
subscription
service to
let
business
owners
submit
their
financial
information
to compare
it with
key
industry
benchmarks
With
QuickBooks
and [other
kinds of]
available
software,
[business
owners]
can
extract
the
information
they need,
he says.
It's just
a little
educational
process to
understand
what those
ratios
mean and
let them
be warning
signs that
they're
going to
get
themselves
into
trouble.
Crystal
Detamore-Rodman
is a
Charlottesville,
Virginia,
writer who
covers the
small-business
finance
market.
This
article
was
published
by
entrepreneur.com