e've
been studying leadership and organizations for more than
thirty-five years and have come to a conclusion: All the
world-class organizations we know are driven by three
critical factors:
Clear vision and direction championed by
top management
Trained and equipped people focused on
implementation of the agreed-upon vision and
direction
Established recognition and positive
consequence systems that sustain the behaviors
and performance that the vision and direction
require
Vision and direction are essential for greatness. In
world-class organizations, every-one has a clear sense
of where the enterprise is going. Only when the leaders
of an organization know that their people understand the
agreed-upon vision and direction can they attend to
strengthening the organization's ability to deliver on
this vision.
The second step in the process of building a
world-class organization--implementation-- is training,
preparing, and equipping people throughout the
organization to live according to the vision and
accomplish the desired goals.
If organizations do not do that, their people will
never take care of their customers. And after all,
profit is the applause you get for taking care of your
customers and creating a motivating environment for your
people.
After vision and direction get things started and
people are trained, equipped, and committed to success,
the question becomes, "What do you do to keep all this
going? World-class organizations establish
recognition and positive consequence systems that
fuel the implementation of the vision and direction, and
they make sure those standards are met or exceeded on an
ongoing basis. These practices communicate a basic
understanding about people: recognition is a universal
need. People everywhere want to be appreciated for their
good efforts, and redirected and coached for any
inappropriate behavior.
Although the greatest impact on performance--ongoing
and future--comes from training and equipping people and
establishing positive recognition and consequence
systems, unless vision and direction are communicated
and well understood by everyone, your organization won't
even be in the game. Why?
Vision helps people make smart choices be-cause their
decisions are being made with the end result in mind. As
goals are accomplished, the answer to "What next?"
be-comes clear. Vision takes into account a larger
picture than the immediate goal. Martin Luther King Jr.
described his vision of a world where people live
together in mutual respect. In his "I Have a Dream"
speech, he described a world where his children "will
not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the
content of their character." He created powerful and
specific images from the values of brotherhood, respect,
and freedom for all--values that resonate with the
founding values of the United States. King's vision has
passed a crucial test: it continues to mobilize and
guide people beyond his lifetime. Vision allows for a
long-term proactive stance--creating what we
want--rather than a short-term reactive stance--getting
rid of what we don't want.
Vision is important for leaders because leadership is
about going somewhere. If you and your people don't know
where you are going, your leadership doesn't matter.
Ken's father, Ted Blanchard, gave a wonderful example of
this. He retired from the Navy early as a captain, even
though he could have stayed on and been promoted to
admiral on his own merits. Ken asked, "Dad, why did you
quit early?" His father answered, "Ken, I hate to say it
but I liked the wartime Navy better than the peacetime
Navy. Not that I liked to fight, but in wartime we knew
what our purpose was and what we were trying to
accomplish. The problem with the peacetime Navy is that
nobody knows what we are supposed to be doing. As a
result, too many leaders think their full-time job is
making other people feel unimportant."
Without a clear vision, an organization
be-comes a self-serving bureaucracy.
Without a clear vision, an organization be-comes a
self-serving bureaucracy. The top managers begin to
think "the sheep are there for the benefit of the
shepherd." All the money, recognition, power, and status
move up the hierarchy, away from the people closest to
the customers, and leadership begins to serve the
leaders and not the organization's larger purpose and
goals. The results of this type of behavior have been
all too evident recently at Enron, World-com, and other
companies.
Once the vision is clarified and shared, the leader
can focus on serving and being responsive to the needs
of the people. The greatest leaders have mobilized
others by coalescing people around a shared vision.
Sometimes leaders don't get it at first, but the great
ones eventually do.
Louis Gerstner Jr. is a perfect example. When he took
the helm of IBM in 1993--amid turmoil and instability as
the company's annual net losses reached a record $8
billion--he was quoted as saying, "The last thing IBM
needs is a vision." However, less than a year later he
conceded that IBM needed to do long-range thinking. An
incredible turnaround arose as a result of that
long-range planning: it became clear that the focus of
strength for the company would be in integrated
solutions. As a result of that clarity, Gerstner
resisted pressures to split the company. In 1995,
delivering the keynote address at the computer industry
trade show, Gerstner articulated IBM's new vision--that
network computing would drive the next phase of industry
growth and would be the company's overarching strategy.
That year, IBM began a series of acquisitions that
positioned services to become the fastest growing
segment of the company, with growth at more than 20
percent per year. This extraordinary turnaround
demonstrated that the most important thing IBM needed to
do was have a vision--a shared vision.
If an organization's vision is a compelling
one, people will think their work is worthwhile
and will become joyful.
Again, while training and equipping people and
establishing positive recognition and consequence
systems will have the greatest impact on performance,
without a clear vision you're going nowhere. If an
organization's vision is a compelling one, people will
think their work is worthwhile and will become joyful.
As wise old Texas entrepreneur Fred Smith--author of
You and Your Network--says, "Real joy in life comes
when you can get in the act of forgetful-ness about
yourself." A compelling vision helps people forget
themselves.
When people share and believe in a vision of what the
organization can be, they generate tremendous energy,
excitement, and passion. They feel they are making a
difference. They build a strong reputation for excellent
products and services. They know what they are doing and
why. There is a strong sense of trust and respect.
Managers don't try to control. They let others assume
responsibility because they know everyone shares the
vision and is clear about their goals and direction.
Everyone assumes responsibility for their own actions.
They take charge of their future rather than passively
waiting for it to happen. There is room for creativity
and risk taking. People can make their contributions in
their own way, and their differences are respected
be-cause people know they are in the same boat
together--all part of a larger whole going "full steam
ahead!"
Effective Versus Ineffective
Vision Statements
lot of organizations already have vision
statements, but most of these statements seem irrelevant
when you look at the organization and where it's going.
Are these vision statements misguided, and if so, how
can they be improved?
The purpose of a vision statement is to create an
aligned organization where every-one is working together
toward the same desired ends. The vision provides
guidance for daily decisions so that people are moving
in the right direction, not working at cross-purposes
with one another.
How do you know if your vision statement works?
Here's the test: Is it hidden in a for-gotten file or
framed on a wall solely for decoration? If so, it's not
working. Is it used to guide everyday decision making?
If the answer is yes, your vision statement is working.
Create a Compelling Vision
real vision statement
reveals what business a company is in. It identifies not
just the products or services offered, but the company's
core reason for existence--its purpose. It focuses
organizational energy. A real vision statement provides
broad guidelines for how to proceed in fulfilling the
organization's purpose, and a real vision statement
offers clear pictures of what success looks like. We
have found three elements that constitute a compelling
vision:
Significant purpose: What business are
you in?
A picture of the future: What will the
future look like if you are living according to your
purpose?
Clear values: How do you want people to
behave when they are working according to your
purpose and on your picture of the future?
Significant Purpose
urpose
is your organization's reason for existence. It answers
the question "Why?" rather than just explaining what you
do. It clarifies--from your customer's viewpoint--what
business you are really in. CNN is not in the
entertainment business. Their customers are busy people
who need breaking news on demand. Their business is to
provide hard news as it unfolds--not to provide
entertainment. According to CNN, the typical family
today is too busy to sit in front of the television at
7:00 P.M. Dad has a second job, Mom is working late, and
the kids are involved in activities. Therefore, CNN's
purpose is to provide news on demand.
Walt Disney was a genius at creating a compelling
vision. When he started his theme parks, he was clear on
their purpose. He said, "We're in the happiness
business." That is very different from being in the
theme park business. Clear purpose drives everything the
cast members (employees) do with their guests
(customers). Great organizations have a deep and noble
sense of purpose--a significant purpose--that
inspires excitement and commitment. When work is
meaningful and connected to what we truly desire, we are
able to unleash a productive and creative power we never
imagined.
Picture of the Future
pictureof the end
result should not be vague. It should be something you
can actually see. CNN's picture of the future is to be
viewed in every nation on the planet in English and in
the language of that region. Walt Disney's picture of
the future was expressed in the charge he gave every
cast member: "Keep the same smile on people's faces when
they leave the park as when they enter." He didn't care
whether a guest was in the park two hours or ten hours.
He just wanted to keep them smiling. After all, they
were in the happiness business. Your picture should
focus on the end result, not the process for getting
there.
Clear Values
alues
provide guidelines on how you should proceed as you
pursue your purpose and picture of the future. They
answer the questions, "What do I want to live by?" and
"How?" They need to be clearly described so you know
exactly what behaviors demonstrate that the value is
being lived. They need to be consistently acted on or
they are only good intentions. The values of CNN are to
provide accurate, responsible journalism and to be
responsive to the news needs of people around the world.
Fewer than 10 percent of organizations around the
world have clear, written values. Most organizations
that do have values either have too many values or they
are not rank ordered. Research shows that people can't
focus on more than three or four values or those values
will not really have an impact on behavior. Also, values
must be rank ordered to be effective. Why? Because life
is about value conflicts. When these conflicts arise,
people need to know which value they should focus on.
Walt Disney intuitively knew this when he ranked safety
ahead of other values--courtesy, the show, and
efficiency. Why did he do that? Because he knew that if
a guest left the park on a stretcher, that guest would
not have the same smile on her face that was present
when she entered the park. So, if a cast member hears a
scream while being courteous to a guest, he excuses
himself immediately and focuses on the number one
value--safety. A vision is compelling when it helps
people understand what business they're really in,
provides a picture of the desired future, and offers
value guidelines that help people make daily decisions.
Once you have a compelling vision, goals can be set that
help people focus their energy on a day-to-day basis.
But these goals will now take on bigger meaning, because
they are seen in the context of a clear vision.
For a vision to endure, you need all three elements:
significant purpose, a picture of the future, and clear
values. In 1960, John F. Kennedy articulated a picture
of the future for the Apollo moon project: to place a
man on the moon by the end of the 1960s and bring him
home safely. To achieve that goal, NASA overcame
seemingly insurmountable obstacles. It was not an
enduring vision, however, because no one had clearly
articulated a significant purpose for the program, nor
had they established values to guide the journey. Were
we doing it to "beat the Russians," "begin the Space
Defense Initiative," or--in the spirit of Star Trek--"to
boldly go where no one has gone before"? Once Kennedy's
picture of the future was achieved, NASA never recreated
the energy of the original program.
Make Your Vision a Reality
f
you are clear about your vision and honest about your
present realities, you don't have to figure everything
out. Things start happening of their own accord. Vision
is a lot more than putting a plaque on the wall. A real
vision is lived, not framed. For vision to become a
reality, what's important is how it's created, how it's
communicated, and how it's lived.
How It's Created
he
process of creating the vision is as important as what
the vision says. Instead of simply taking the top
management off on a retreat to put the vision together
and then announcing the vision, encourage dialogue about
the vision. Allow others to have an opportunity to help
shape the vision, to put their thumbprint on it. This
will deepen their understanding and commitment as well
as create a better vision.
How It's Communicated
Creating a vision is a journey, not a
one-time activity.
reating
a vision--for your organization or department, for your
work, and for your life--is a journey, not a one-time
activity.
The more you focus on your vision, the
clearer it will become and the more deeply you
will understand it.
In some organizations a vision statement may be found
framed on walls but provide no guidance or, worse, have
nothing to do with how things actually are. This turns
people off. Visioning is an ongoing process; you need to
keep it alive. It's important to keep talking about the
vision and referring to it as much as possible. Max De
Pree, legendary chairman of Herman Miller, said that in
his visionary role he had to be like a third-grade
teacher. He had to keep on saying it over and over and
over again until people got it right, right, right! As
chief spiritual officer of The Ken Blanchard Companies,
Ken leaves an inspirational voice-mail message every
morning re-minding more than 250 people what our vision
and values are. The more you focus on your vision, the
clearer it will become and the more deeply you will
understand it. In fact, aspects of what you thought was
the vision may change over time, but the essence of it
will remain.
How It's Lived
he
moment you identify your vision, you need to behave as
if it were happening right now. Your actions need to be
congruent with your vision. As others see you living the
vision, they will believe you are serious and it will
help to deepen their understanding and commitment. Two
strategies will support your efforts to live your
vision:
Always focus on your vision. If an
obstacle or un-foreseen event throws you off course,
set a new course rather than trying to get back on
the old one. Be prepared to change your goals if
necessary. Change is bound to happen. Unforeseen
events are bound to occur. Find a way to reframe
what is happening as a challenge or opportunity.
Show the courage of commitment. True
commitment begins when you take action. There will
be fears; feel them and move ahead. It takes courage
to create a vision and it takes courage to act on
it. In the words of Goethe, "Whatever you can do, or
dream you can, begin it. Boldness has genius, power
and magic in it."
While top management should involve as many people as
possible in shaping and communicating vision and
direction, the ultimate responsibility for making
sure that these are done lies with the hierarchical
leadership.
Visioning Role
eople
look to their formal leaders for vision and direction,
but if an enterprise is to be effective and live its
vision, people throughout the organization must be
responsive to this vision--knowing who they are,
where they are going, and what will guide their journey.
To make that happen, the implementation role has to
begin.
The implementation role--empowering others to live
according to the organization's vision and direction--is
where most organizations get into trouble. The
traditional pyramid is kept alive and well, leaving
customers uncared for at the bottom of the hierarchy.
All the energy in the organization moves up the
hierarchy as people try to please and be responsive to
their bosses. Now the bureaucracy's rules and policies
and procedures carry the day. This leaves un-prepared
and uncommitted customer-contact people to quack like
ducks: "It's our policy. I didn't make the rules--I just
work here. Do you want to talk to my supervisor? Quack!
Quack! Quack!"
There is a way to avoid the duck syndrome. Once the
vision is set, people are committed to it, and
implementation has begun, the traditional pyramidal
hierarchy must be turned upside down so that the
frontline people, who are closest to the customers, are
at the top. Here they can be responsible--able to
respond to their customers. In this scenario, leaders
serve and are responsive to the needs of people,
training and equipping them to accomplish goals and live
according to the vision and direction of the
organization.
Implementation Role
when the front-line customer-contact people
are treated as responsible owners of the vision,
they can soar like eagles rather than quack like
ducks.
f
the leaders of an organization do not resonate with and
respond to the needs and desires of their people, these
individuals will not take good care of their customers.
But when the front-line customer-contact people are
treated as responsible owners of the vision, they can
soar like eagles rather than quack like ducks. Now your
vision can really take on life.
While traveling one year, Ken experienced a beautiful
example of the difference between a "duck pond"
organization and an organization that permits people to
soar like eagles. He was heading to the airport for a
trip that was going to take him to four different cities
in one week. As he approached the airport, he realized
that he had forgotten his license and didn't have a
passport either. Not having time to go back home to get
them and still make the flight, he had to be creative.
Ken de-scribes what happened:
"Only one of my books has my picture on the cover--Everyone's
a Coach--which I wrote with Don Shula, the legendary
NFL football coach from the Miami Dolphins. So when I
got to the airport I ran into the bookstore and,
luckily, they had a copy of my book. Fortunately, the
first airline I had to go to was South-west Airlines. As
I was checking my bag at the curb, the porter asked to
see my identification. I said, 'I feel badly. I don't
have a driver's license or a passport. But will this
do?' And I showed him the cover of the book.
"He shouted out, 'The man knows Shula! Put him in
first class!' Of course, Southwest doesn't have first
class. Everybody out by the curbside check-in started to
high-five me. I was like a hero."
Why did that happen? Herb Kelleher, who founded
Southwest, had a clear vision when he started that
company. Not only did he want to give his customers the
lowest possible price, but he also wanted to give them
the best possible service. He set up the whole
organization (including the recognition and positive
con-sequence systems) to empower everyone--right down to
the frontline baggage-check folks--to make decisions and
use their brains so they could create raving-fan
customers.
The next airline Ken had to go to was one that has
been battling financial troubles: "When I tried to check
in with the same procedure as at Southwest, the guy at
the curb check-in said, 'No way. Quack! Quack! I can't
do that. You'd better go to the ticket counter. Quack!
Quack!' When I got to the ticket counter the person
there said, 'I'll have to get my supervisor. Quack!
Quack!' The supervisor came over and when he saw the
book I was using for an ID he essentially said, 'Let me
get my supervisor. Quack! Quack!'"
It took four different people before they would
consider letting Ken use a picture on a book as
identification. At Southwest Airlines, that was not even
a second thought. Herb Kelleher (who has recently
retired and turned over the presidency to his former
executive assistant) felt that policies should be
followed, but that people could use their brains in
interpreting them. Why do they ask for identification at
the airport? To make sure that the person getting on the
plane is the same person as the name on the ticket. That
was an easy decision for the Southwest Airlines'
frontline per-son. But in the troubled airline, the
hierarchy is alive and well. All the energy is moving
away from the customers and up the hierarchy--away from
pleasing customers and toward serving the hierarchy and
following the policies, procedures, rules, and
regulations to the letter.
Do we have to say anything more about the power of
having a clear vision in your organization? That vision
calls an organization to be truly great, not solely to
beat the competition and get big numbers. A magnificent
vision articulates peoples' hopes and dreams, touches
their hearts and spirits, and helps them see how they
can contribute. It starts everything in the right
direction and--if followed up by effective
implementation, positive consequence, and
sustain-ability strategies--will keep things going in
that right direction. Vision is the difference between
business as usual and a world-class organization.
Print citation:
Blanchard, Ken and Stoner, Jesse. "The Vision
Thing: Without It You'll Never be a World-Class
Organization" Leader to Leader. 31
(Winter 2004): 21-28.
This article is available on the Leader to
Leader Institute Web site,
http://leadertoleader.org/leaderbooks/L2L/winter2004/blanchardandstoner.html.