It's such a lovely old-fashioned quote, isn't it? "Whip with a switch" from the days of horses and horse carriages. And I would think that if you used a switch without leaves it would certainly tingle, though these days we shudder a little at the thought of beating the poor animal.
Nevertheless, writing as he was, in his time, Henry Ward has made a timeless point - waffling does not drive home searching truths.
And there's another wonderful term "searching truths". Ah! If all the points I make when I speak cause my audiences to search their beliefs and themselves, I would be very happy!
I wish you (and me) speaking experiences that drive us and our points home ... in fine style!
And that is what it feels like to own the stage, to really connect, to be in flow as a speaker.
I don't like it.
I like Florien Mueck.
If you can get to his YouTube channel, do, he's worth watching.
But I wish he hadn't said that, or hadn't been quoted as saying that.
Starting with a negative.
No, there is no perfection.
I live in a household of sporting people, and the shelves are lined with trophies. In any sporting competition, there are distinct winners and losers. A swimming race, say, takes a measured amount of time and the fastest wins. Simple and cut-and-dried (usually!)
A speech on the other hand ... well! I have won many speaking competitions since about the age of 12. I have lost just as many. People come to me afterwards and tell me they thought I won. Sometimes I agreed, sometimes not. Despite the number of very well articulated criteria, there will always be that element of subjectivity involved. I know. I also judge!
So if there is no cut-and-dried "best" speaker, how can there ever be a "perfect" speaker, or a perfect speech?
Perfect according to whom? Perfect according to what criteria?
What if, on the other hand, we went to the second part of this quote and look at a speaking high.
What does that look like? What does that feel like?
To me, it feels like being in flow
- speaking fluently and with enthusiasm
- connecting with members of the audience so that they respond with emotion, or they participate
- it can feel powerful
- it can feel gratifying
- it can feel something close to perfection
And if we looked at the audience members after the speech, they would be doing what we, as speakers, aimed to have them do - repeating, remembering, rehiring, buying, changing, being motivated, or any number of other things we had designed.
It's what keeps me speaking, meeting the challenge to be the best I can be, to climb higher and higher towards
no, not a mountain top,
not a peak
not perfection even, whatever that may be,
but certainly to more highs and greater heights.
And of course the corollary is that we all need to avoid becoming complacent, thinking that there is no better in us, no better experience we an provide, no need to strive or create anything new or better.
So, yes, Florian, I agree with you, and the quote stirred me to do that!!
And it's what I want for all of us here - you, Florian, me and all of our fellow speakers and readers.
[Quotation about public speaking] The success of your presentation depends on more than your knowledge
“No audience ever complained about a presentation or speech being too short”
― Stephen Keague, The Little Red Handbook of Public Speaking and Presenting
[Quotation about public speaking] Public speaking will have its place
"As long as there are human rights to be defended; as long as there are great interests to be guarded; as long as the welfare of nations is a matter for discussion so long will public speaking have it place." ~ William Jennings Bryan
Public Speaking has its place
In my current obsession with storytelling, I have discovered a Hopi Proverb which says the "Those who tell the stories rule the world."
Leaders everywhere are those who give their followers something to believe in, a narrative that explains the present and paints a future.
And leaders are not just those in government or religion.
They lead in business, they lead in our institutions, they lead in our families.
We all have the capacity to be a leader at some time.
I am only thankful that the skills of public speaking are there to give us the power to lead and to create a world with values that we can uphold.